Hollywood, please stop shitting on my childhood

While on vacation, I went to see the Fantastic Four movie (the only reason it was worth it was because it was the first move I had seen in theatres in over a year) and had the dubious pleasure to see a preview for the Transformers movie. Now, despite the pretty CG, I knew I wasn’t going to want to see it because the only woman I saw was The Hot Love Interest, and really that’s an archetype that has been done to death and then some.

But I didn’t know how bad it was until reviews started popping up.

On Racism:
Nora on Angry Black Woman wrote More stereotypes than meet the eye (she has the same post up on her LJ) where she talks about the various racial stereotypes used in the film:

So the nostalgia in this version of Transformers seems to have also resurrected some old-school not-so-hidden messages: black women are nagging mammies who deserve the label bitch; black men are thugs, rappers, cowards, or crooks, and are stupid even when they’re supposed to be smart; Latino men are effete idiots; and even alien robots aren’t safe from token black guy syndrome. Oh, and I almost forgot the moronic Indian customer support guy who symbolizes the real dangers of outsourcing — it’s not only bad for our economy, it’s bad for our troops in wartime — and the Arab villagers whose sole purpose in the film is to be rescued by the tough-talking American soldiers. (Also see discussion on the Wiscon panel “What These People Need is a Honky”.)

On Sexism:
After finding out that Arcee wasn’t in the movie because they would have to “explain” her apparent female-ness and they were afraid of being seen as “trying to appease women with a pink Transformer”, Ragnell wrote In case you forgot, I hate everyone.:

Why is being a girl so fucking special? Why is it that every other fucking robot has a male fucking voice and no one questions why they have gender coding but the fucking second you bring in a female voice and god forbid you put it in a feminine color you have to suddenly explain why everyone has gender?

Oh, I know. We automatically assume everything is male. Male is the default. Male is neutral and being a girl is some sort of freakishness that can only be explained as thrown in their to try and appease the women.

Ariel wrote about the problematic handling of The Hot Love Interest, Mikaela, in the post Transformers: Sexism in Disguise:

I started off with a sour taste for Mikaela. During the first hour, she does two cool things: she knows how to fix Sam’s car and she walks away from her boyfriend (for good) when he calls her his little bunny. But also within that hour, the film establishes that Mikaela is oblivious to Sam is despite being his schoolmate for years, dates jerks because she likes guys with big arms and tight abs, admits she hides her knowledge about cars from guys so they’ll like her, with a vacant facial expression asks Sam if he thinks she is shallow, and is called a jock concubine and hoe by Sam’s friend. It’s a nice guy trope: nerdy but deserving Sam is overlooked because girls are shallow. The traits don’t especially set her up sympathetically unless we’re supposed to desire her for her body and Sam’s unsettling infatuation.

And in Transformers Skye wrote about her decidedly mixed feelings regarding the character:

I’d also rather see a movie where we don’t have to go through the “I’d do her” phase with a female character before accepting her as a person. Granted, this was from the point of view of the horny boy who saves the world and may have been correct characterization for him, but I don’t give out stars for that. Finally, I’d like to have seen more women in speaking roles. We get one who’s beautiful and one who’s brainy (but also beautiful), and that’s it.

So, yeah. Not planning on seeing that movie, unless it’s on cable TV when I happen to be in North America and I have an urge to write a scathing movie review. I can’t say I’m surprised that the movie seems to have exceeded even my expectations of awfulness, as I agree with Nora’s assessment of Hollywood in the second to last paragraph of her post (you did read it, right?), although I would add that it obviously extends to gender issues and other anti-oppression issues as well.

But, still, as my standards for entertainment go up and the quality of available entertainment goes down, it’s becoming harder and harder to find ways to escape from the hurts, injustices, and annoyances of real life. As hard as it might be for some people to grasp, there are times when I just want to watch mechs destroy each other without having to sit through “plot” that reminds me of how bigoted the world really is.

Sigh. I just know that at the ripe old age of 25 (my birthday is only 9 days away! well, 9 days if you live in Japan, anyway) I’m going to become one of those crotchety old people whose sole entertainment is reading books and complains about how these newfangled inventions like the tee-vee are ruining civilization…

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Add to favorites
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
This entry was posted in Film and televison, Gender Caste, Gender issues, Racism, The Evil -ism's. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Hollywood, please stop shitting on my childhood

  1. Lake Desire says:

    Thanks for the link! I realized after I wrote that post that the reason I didn’t even mind that they left out the female transformers is because in a world that treats Mikaela as awful as the one in Transformers does, can you blame the Autobots for adopting male personas?

  2. Almost all of the mech fighting occurs in the last 20 minutes of the movie. The fight was actually a little lengthy, given that up until that point the movie hadn’t even really focused on the robots very much.

    If you want to ignore all of the other stuff and just enjoy a good robot showdown, fast forward to two hours in and settle down to watch Megatron duke it out with Optimus Prime. No plot required.

  3. Jo says:

    If you want to ignore all of the other stuff and just enjoy a good robot showdown, fast forward to two hours in and settle down to watch Megatron duke it out with Optimus Prime. No plot required.

    Yeah, that’s what I was hoping would be the movie. I even have friends (do I need the single quotes to indicate dubiousness?) who have said it is the geek movie of the summer.

    Apparently, it’s also the Typical Hollywood -Ist Trash of the summer as well.

    And I was going to go see it. Boo hiss.

    Thanks for all the great links, anyway. If it can’t be entertaining, at least it can be more fodder to sharpen my feminist teeth on.

  4. Pingback: I Read the Internets - 7/14/07

  5. Brinstar says:

    I decided not to see the movie. I think Cameron has the right idea: fast forward to the fight scenes if you see it at all. :)

  6. Pingback: Feministe » Criticizing the things you love

  7. ty says:

    um…ok this is kind of weird i mean i seen the movie and mikila wasn’t treated badly and it was a really good movie she helped out and all but come on it was coming from sams point of veiew and he happened to be strongly attracted to to the point of tring to impress her.why do you look for sexism,racism and other things when there are known

  8. tekanji says:

    ty: No one is “looking” for anything, we merely see what is there. I suggest that you read this post on the matter to educate yourself. Also, I recommend that you re-read the discussion rules, especially the part where it says that this blog is an anti-oppression blog. What we do here is discuss things like stereotyping in the media. If you don’t like it, you have the option not to read it, but I will not tolerate any more dismissive phrases like “why do you look for sexism, racism, and other things”.

    As per Mikaela, sexism is more than blatant misogyny. I suggest that you check out the FAQ on sexual objectification over at the Feminism 101 blog. It’s not that Mikaela was treated as badly as she could have been, but rather she wasn’t treated as well as she should have been.

  9. The isms are back for another go-round in Transformers 2!

Comments are closed.