Official Shrub.com Blog
Home Log in   About Us Discussion Rules
October 6, 2005
Media Girl on How Progressive is not Liberal
by @ 1:50 pm

In her post, When the straw man misses the reality bus, media girl discusses many things, one of which is the difference between liberals and progressives.

Here’s an excerpt:

The first — and main — mistake here is equating “progressive” with “liberal.” Now I’m one of the first to admit that there’s a lot of overlap. But I feel, at least from my perspective, that there are some important distinctions between the two: progressive means having a dynamic, proactive government that actively participates in the economy and the fabric of our culture, while liberal comes with assumptions about the kinds of programs the government provides. In some ways, liberalism goes beyond progressivism in the manner and approach of such programs, while progressivism goes beyond liberalism in the scope and goals of what a proactive government can achieve. At least that’s how I see it. (For the record, I consider myself a progressive who is sympathetic to the liberal cause.)

I also consider myself a progressive, not a liberal. I would actually go further than media girl did and say that liberals are often conflated with Democrats, although the two aren’t technically synonomous.

Anyway, it’s a great read that I’m too lazy to go through in detail, so if you want to know more you’ll have to go read it for yourself. I promise you won’t regret it if you do.

  [link]
Filed under Politics

5 Responses to “Media Girl on How Progressive is not Liberal”

  1. Following Edge » Helping out... to a point says:

    [...] Andrea (another great feminist, liberal (oops) progressive blogger) added the plug-in to Shrub.com as well. It’s really rewarding to see software I wrote helping people use these sites. No comments yet. [...]


  2. Winter says:

    I’ve never really understood the meaning of “progressive” although I notice more people in the UK are now using the term. Over here I think we’ve generally tended to refer to ourselves as conservatives, liberals, leftys or even radicals.


  3. Sour Duck says:

    Winter - there’s a good definition over at Wikipedia.


  4. Monkey! says:

    Thank you for this… this is just what I’ve been looking for, because I also get tired of the generalizations and was thinking of writing something myself!


  5. Winter says:

    Thanks for the definition SD.Once I’ve managed to digest it, I might be able to understand this discussion better!


Leave a Reply

Before posting a comment, you must read this blog's discussion rules. By posting here, you agree to abide by the rules listed. If you do not, your comment will most likely not be published. Trolling, flaming, and personal attacks will do nothing but get you banned.

  • Ableism 101

  • Blog Carnivals

  • Blog Vanity

  • Community Blogs

  • Contributors' Sites

  • Culture Blogs

  • Dear Privileged Groups:

  • Disability Activist Feminists

  • Feminism 101

  • Feminism 303

  • Feminist Gamers

  • Feminist Groups

  • Feminist Men

  • Feminist Parents

  • Feminists of Colour

  • Feminists on Sexuality

  • Gaming Geekery

  • Geeky Feminists

  • Geeky Resources

  • Health Products

  • LJ Communities

  • More Feminists

  • Online News & Journals

  • Other Groups

  • Personal is Political Blogs

  • Political Feminists

  • Pop-culture Blogs

  • Privilege 101

  • Privilege Checklists

  • Queer Activist Blogs

  • Queer Feminists

  • Race Relations 101

  • Racial Activist Blogs

  • Reproductive Rights

  • Resources

  • Science and Technology Blogs

  • Services

  • Tag-team Feminism

  • Technology Groups

  • Transgender Resources

  • Unclassified Blogs

  • Useful Plugins

  • WordPress

  • All original content Official Shrub.com Blog is copyrighted by Shrub.com; any other material used with permission or according to fair use remains the sole property of the owner. Please contact the the site administrator for further details regarding acceptable use policy.

    Contents and Graphics Copyrighted © Andrea Rubenstein
    Efficient Recently Commented Posts plugin © Michael Moore.
    Official Shrub.com Blog is proudly powered by WordPress.

    Shrub.com Logo © 2004, Andrea Rubenstein
    About
    Shrub.com's official blog is a space for our members to share their opinions on politics, culture, feminism, video games, and whatever else interests them.
    Recent Comments
    Categories
  • All
  • Anti-oppression activism (1)
  • Carnivals, Blog Against -ism Days, etc. (49)
  • Censorship (2)
  • Childfree Issues (9)
  • Companies Behaving Badly (26)
  • Discrimination (10)
  • Features (1)
  • Feminism (234)
  • Gender essentialism (70)
  • Just plain cool (1)
  • Link Blogging (22)
  • Multiculturalism (26)
  • Personal (62)
  • Politics (73)
  • Popular Culture (197)
  • Privilege (71)
  • Queer Issues (27)
  • Religion (12)
  • Science (27)
  • Series (38)
  • Sex, sexuality, and sexual politics (64)
  • Shrub.com Related (65)
  • Technology (18)
  • Teh Funnay (16)
  • The Evil -ism's (116)
  • Blog Search
    Archives
    TTLB Ecosystem
    RSS Feeds
    Valid XHTML
    Other
    Valid XHTML
    XFN
    Boycott Staforce

    StatCounter